Hi Judes,
I am really sorry that your implant has not worked out.
Its a diffiuclt decision. I understand completely your reservations about going through a long surgery after getting through your treatment from b/c. As you know, there is no right or wrong. Just trying to work out what you want to do, when maybe you dont really want either!!
I can add my experiences to the others. But like you have a 'failed' reconstruction.
I had breast cancer in right breast in 2009. Had the usual chemo. rads and surgery -WLE. In May 2011, learned I had a brca1 mutation (in case you dont know this is an inherited mutation which increases the risk of b/c bilateral b/c and ovarian cancer). I agonised for months over risk-reducing surgery. Like you, could not face a long operation and being ill again. But, did not want breast cancer again. I had limited recon options as I am slim, with small breasts and needed 2 breasts, not one! Had my surgery in Feb. - implants and strattice.
To cut a long story short, I had to have a completion mastecomy (ie removal of implant and skin/tissue) due to poor healing/infection due to previous rads of right breast in June. The op was relatively straight-forward but emotionally its been very hard, much harder than I thought. I dont really like being lop-sided, or that its so obvious in the clothes I would normally wear. I cant wear a proper prosthetic as I still have not healed - again this is due to rads (although planning a trip to Nicola Jane next week, so watch this space!). ATM just wearing baggy t-shirts/scarves but not really a long term solution.
My advice is not to rush into any decision (unless there is a medical reason). Take time to work out what you want. Maybe ask to talk to a counsellor, or someone on the BCC helpline? Dont know if it is possible to have implant removed and see how you get on, with the knowledge that you could have DIEP in the future?
For what its worth, if I could have reconstruction (atm this is doubtful due to poor healing), I would be really torn. As much as I hate being 'one-breasted', I think another op might be the end of me and so I have to try and learn to make the best of what I have. I know I might change my mind on this in the future and as things progress it might become an option, but I just dont think I could do it. Also, while there are many ladies who are happy with their reconstructions, there are others who have adjusted to living without reconstructions.
Good luck with your decision, Rattles x