68590members
360738posts
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Lumpectomy or mastectomy

5 REPLIES 5
Highlighted
Member

Re: Lumpectomy or mastectomy

I too had this dilemma. 14 years ago I didn't have a choice and had to have a mastectomy. Now I have it in my other boob and I can have mastectomy or lumpectomy.

I've been going back and forward thinking lumpectomy will be a smaller op, quicker recovery etc, I'm having radio regardless as have lymph node involvement and chemo.

I have decided the best thing for me (and this is where you can way up your own options) I want it gone, I don't want another reaccurance in my breast tissue, so having a mastectomy. I am aware it could potentially come back in my chest wall, but I really can't change that. 

 

It's so sad we even have to think about this. You have to weigh up the pros and cons for you and your personal circumstances and take it from there, don't let people sway you, it's your body and you have to live with it after.

 

I'm happy I have now made my mind up, I've done it before I can do it again.

 

I did have LD flap recon, and as long as it hasn't spread will look to this for the future. 

Good luck xxxxx

Highlighted
Member

Re: Lumpectomy or mastectomy

Hi Tili, 

Thank you so much for your reply, it really helps to hear about other people’s experiences and outcomes.  
I think once I go back for the results of my MRI I may find it easier as I will hopefully have a clearer picture or the decision made for me x💕

Highlighted
Member

Re: Lumpectomy or mastectomy

Hi Annie

I must admit I thought the same just remove the breast and get rid of it, but now the initial shock has worn off I am considering all options.  
I was told today that all three tumours are grade2, ER+, HER2-.  I also had my MRI today so am hoping that I will know if I even have a choice to save the breast at my next appointment.  If I do I might just follow your lead and ask the same question of my consultant. 😊💕

Highlighted
Community Champion

Re: Lumpectomy or mastectomy

Hi Carole, whatever decision you make must be right for you. I was diagnosed three years ago and immediately asked for the breast to be removed. I could think of nothing worse than my body having this ugly intruder. My surgeon, bless him, spent a long time explaining options backed by research. In my case ( 1 largeish tumour near nipple, ER+ HR-) the survival rate with a lumpectomy Is no different to a mastectomy. Treatment is always patient led, but I found it hard to absorb everything thrown at me. I did find what i think is a cracking solution for difficult questions....I held my surgeons hand, looked him dead in the eye and asked...” if I was your mum would you send her this route?” Without hesitation he said yes. This allowed me to sign the paperwork with great confidence. Obviously you have more to consider if it’s a mastectomy such as reconstruction, but as I was 70 at the time I wasn’t going to do that as I felt I had little time left! Also, I only needed my boobs to feed my babies and I’d done that!!! I found the lumpectomy very easy. No probs with surgery, and good anaesthetics were a blessing. Good luck with your decision. 🍀💐

Highlighted
Member

Re: Lumpectomy or mastectomy

Morning Carole,

firstly, wishing you lots of luck with the decision you make. Having had both a mastectomy 5years ago on the right side, didn’t need radiotherapy or chemotherapy afterward,, last November had lumpectomy on the right side followed by radiotherapy for me I found recovery much quicker from the lumpectomy. As you say the MRI may make the decision for you. Speak with you consultant and breast cancer nurse. Hugs brave lady 

keep well and safe Tili xx

 

Highlighted
Member

Lumpectomy or mastectomy

I have recently been diagnosed with 3 cancerous lumps in my left breast. One on outer edge of my breast under my arm and two at the bottom, the largest being 11mm.  At present I have been told I have the choice of lumpectomy, although this may change after my MRI.  
I Continually flit back and forth about what might be the better option.  I’m worried about reoccurrence if I opt for a lumpectomy but on the other hand I’m worried about recovery and reconstruction if I opt for a mastectomy. I’m so worried I will make the wrong decision.