fuel for the fire OK I accept all that you say and I too have taken issue with people who tell me that \'my positive attitude\' will get me through this (!) however we must not be guilty of \'throwing the baby out with the bathwater\' here.
Even if complementary therapies have nothing at all to offer, other than the placebo effect then are we right to dismiss that? Yesterday on BBC 4 a doctor stated that, in a trial (not sure for what) 40% of the people had recovered but had only had a placebo. I think we are wrong to dismiss such results as failure just because they are unexplained. 40%! If the chalk pill did not cure them then what did?
Doctors insist on treating our diseases (thank goodness) but do not/cannot treat us as individuals. The more I read, the more I realise what complex creatures we are. Our medical information is increasing at an exponential rate and it would be impossible for one Doctor to know all there is to know about one of our systems (eg immune system) never mind the whole person.
We know that people\'s mental state can hasten their death (one partner dying shortly after the loss of the first is just one example) and we also know that the \'placebo effect\' is very real; what is harder to establish is why it should work for one person and not for another. What happens in the medical profession is that these \'miracles\' are taken as \'odd anomalies\' in the tried and tested medical world and, for our poor relatives (and the snake oil merchants) it is seen as \'proof\' that we can, with superhuman effort, beat the odds and make our miraculous recovery. Our loved ones \'will\' us to get better and the medics apply \'rationality\' and probability.
Perhaps the answer is somewhere in that very complex middle ground - the mind and body are inexorably tied, but how? I will not throw out the Herbalists, the Healers and the long distance runners and will exercise a balanced approach, taking from each what sustains me. I will continue to refuse to believe that the cancer is my fault, and will tackle anyone who says otherwise, but my belief in the body\'s ability to correct itself has nothing to do with guilt. Somehow or other my body got out of balance and has the ability to regain that balance (sometimes with a lot of medical help) whether that balance can be regained is what is at issue for me - the means are not so contentious and \'virtuous struggle\' just doesn\'t register.
Thanks Bernie and JaneRA for, once again, allowing me to get \'stuff\' off my chest - its quite cathartic and probably very good for me (joke).
Blondie
... View more